Reflections about Universal Suffrage

On August 31st, 2014, the National People’s Congress Standing Committee (NPCSC) made its pronouncement about the selection of the HKSAR Chief Executive in 2017, through a document entitled “Decision of the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress on Issues Relating to the Selection of the Chief Executive of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region by Universal Suffrage and on the Method for Forming the Legislative Council of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region in the Year 2016”, hereinafter referred to as “the Decision”.

It was an important day in the history of Hong Kong. So important, in fact, that millions of Hong Kong people proceeded to watch the Miss Hong Kong Pageant 2014 Finals instead of reading the Decision, let alone thinking or discussing about it. The Brave New World is upon us.

Ranting aside, I am writing to convey my thoughts about the situation, and raise some questions in the process.

OCLP Is Doing It Wrong

There, I said it. Some people believe that I’m pro-OCLP. I’m not. But I’m not against it either. 

The problem with the OCLP is that they gave the establishment a break by invoking “international standards”.

“International standards” is ineffective as an argument for a simple reason: standards don’t say anything about the underlying fundamental principles of morality and justice.

Certainly, a respectable standard about democracy and human rights is formulated with some presupposed fundamental principles of morality and justice, but it is not the fundamental principle; it cannot replace the fundamental principles. When we demand that a system meet some international standard, the authority can arbitrarily reject it on technical grounds “because it doesn’t apply to our special case”, as we just witnessed in Mr Leung’s response.

Instead, we need to take the fight to them and directly point out the blatant inequality and manipulative nature of the establishment’s proposal. We need not refer to “international standards” to perceive inequality and contradictions. It would be intellectually more taxing, but ultimately I believe it will be more effective and more fruitful. You can get away on technicalities, but you cannot get away on ethics.

One might observe that the Basic Law clearly states the selection of candidates by a nomination committee as the ultimate aim. What this entails is that we need to also challenge the Basic Law on ethical grounds. We need to keep in mind that the law is not absolute, that it is arbitrary to various degrees; otherwise there would be no raison d’être for a Legislative Council at all. Again, it would be a difficult fight, but it would be a fight that the authority cannot easily flee from.

“Broadly Representative”

The Decision stipulates that candidates to the Chief Executive election in 2017 shall be nominated by “a broadly representative nominating committee” (my italics). A look at the composition of the nominating committee reveals what is meant by “broadly representative” and what values the establishment holds.

There are 1200 seats in the nominating committee, divided into four sectors of equal size.

The first sector, i.e. a full quarter (300), is “the industrial, commercial, and financial sectors”. It is comprised of individuals and corporate members, representing mostly employers, and big-money businesses – in other words, corporate interests. Somehow, corporations, with their concentration of power into private hands, have the right to pick Chief Executive candidates for us.

In contrast, in the third sector, “the labour, social services, religious and other sectors”, the labour subsector only takes 60 seat, yet there is no doubt that non-professional labour far outnumber high management and employers in the society.

This mean that any entity with enough money is given more voice than the people with lower income. Again, note that I’m using the word “entity”: any organization with some kind of “collective will” and a bunch of wealthy people behind it is given more voice than real human beings.

What gives them the right to have a voice at all, let alone more voice than real people?

Take a look at the name of the third sector, too: “the labour, social services, religious and other sectors”. That’s right, this is the “miscellaneous” sector. Not just any kind of miscellaneous sector, but the kind where “dissidents” – people who most strongly oppose the Central Government and the collusion between private power and policy makers – are jammed in and sharing a small number of seats out of 300. Since any person who wishes to run for Chief Executive needs only obtain the support of a little over half the nominating committee, the NPCSC has effectively round the opposition into a minority group and is telling any Chief Executive hopeful that they may skip wooing that group at their convenience.

The 50% Rule

The Decision stipulates, as I just mentioned, that any Chief Executive hopeful needs only the support of over 50% of the nominating committee in order to be nominated as a candidate. In other word, you can become a candidate if you obtain support from 601 or more members out of the 1200 total.

At the same time, the NPCSC wishes for the 2017 election to consist of 2 to 3 candidates.

By the pigeon hole principle, this means that each member in the nominating committee have the right to give their support to at least two candidates.

In fact, some of the nominating committee must support more than one candidate: if each committee member supports only one candidate, then there will only ever be one candidate, as only one person can obtain the support of more than half of the committee.

Effectively, this means that committee members have a right to a Plan B candidate.

What gives them the right to have a Plan B while the rest of the population can only vote for one candidate?

In addition, what message is this arrangement sending to the voters? I believe the message is that “it doesn’t really matter whom you vote for” because you are picking either their Plan A or their Plan B.

549 thoughts on “Reflections about Universal Suffrage”

  1. Продам :
    лента транспортерная гост
    продажа рти
    передвижной ленточный конвейер
    лента екатеринбург
    цены в ленте

    Звоните, о цене договоримся.

    Константин Маринич,

    тел: (067) 50-44-185

    ООО «МегаСТО»
    09113, Украина, г. Белая Церковь, ул. Турчанинова, 23
    Телефон: (044) 383-14-05, (04563) 4-69-89
    Web: http://megasto.com.ua

    nJ9p9pwq6C

  2. Привет вроде вы просили?
    Доход от 5000руб. в день!
    Я зарабатываю вот тут http://2017.11-9-90.ru/
    После очень легкой регистрации обязательно пишите мне в скайп spora80
    Все покажу подробно! (сами не разберетесь)
    —————————————————–
    Hi like you asked for?
    Income from 100 $. in a day!
    I earn here http://2017.11-9-90.ru/
    After a very easy registration is required to write to me on Skype spora80
    All show details! (Themselves not be dismantled)

  3. А не подскажете мне здесь качественная шмотка? [url=http://odejda-dlya-vseh.ru]платье на выпускной 4 классаплатье футляр в вертикальную полоскувязаное крючком летнее платьекак отрекламировать выпускное платьеплатье от justin alexander[/url]

  4. If you are an app developer and require mobile marketing then this article is as regards you. We provide app downloads, app installs and app reviews so your app can escape a surmount the leaking it deserves. We eat helped thousands of customers to reach more users in place of their portable app. We grow your app real users, and then your app when one pleases reach the google challenge chart. This works after all expressive developers.

    [url=http://nobuffer.info/profile/lesliferres ]mobile marketing kaplan [/url]

  5. хеллоу
    я делаю ставки вместе с с капперами и свободно зарабатываю в конторе каждый день!
    Заказываю точные ставки на сервисе аналитике Прогноз на матч уотфорд
    с этой группой я поднял уже более 52 366 рублей я очень благодарен точнсоть ставок там 99% всем удачи и с новым годом! эта команда лучшие!

    Сайт futbol-bet.ru создан Владимиром ?нязевым в октябре 2015 года.
    Блог создан для распространения VIP прогнозов на футбол с высокой вероятностью 99%!

    Уже давно не секрет, что хорошая прогноз на вес золота.
    Также, можно сказать и о системе ставок на спорт, как и сколько вы ставите.
    Строить мнение на футбол и другие виды спорта может, каждый из людей. Но удваивать деньги могут лишь еденицы!

    Проект Ставки спорт тв
    Создан для людей, которые мечтают ставки на спорт в букмекерской конторе!
    Наш сервисе предлогает вам: VIP ставки на футбол с проходимостью 99% — это платные прогнозы.
    Составление vip матчей это основной вид деятельности сайта.
    VIP прогнозов на футбол размещаются с целью продажи партнерам проекта для зароботка в букмекерской конторе по предложенной нами системе ставок.
    Для получения ставок напишите нам на почту или вконтакте С уважением Проект futbol-bet.ru Ставки на матчи по футболу

  6. Do you want app installs so you can spread in the app upon chart? Then we can help you. We do take precautions app installs recompense at most 0.04$ per install. We do support app installs seeking both Android and IOS apps. All our installs are from honest users.

    [url=http://gaodangyanw.com/comment/html/index.php?page=1&id=61594 ]buy reviews for your app [/url]

  7. [b]AliExpress рулит!!![/b]

    [url=http://seo-swat.ru//ObZUX][b]AliExpress[/b][/url] – популярный в России китайский гипермаркет товаров: можно купить платье, одежду, аксессуары, обувь, гаджеты, косметику, игрушки, бижутерию, посуду, товары для дома и многое другое… Вы всегда можете найти только сегодня купоны Алиэкспресс, распродажи и актуальные скидки на товары. Сайт Алиэкспресс полностью на русском языке.

    Лови момент и купи желаемую одежду, электронику или игрушки для своего ребёнка по ценам, которые порой в несколько раз ниже чем на прилавках магазинов!
    [b]Почтовая доставка абсолютно бесплатно не зависимо от суммы заказа!!![/b]
    Это крупнейший во всём мире интернет – магазин!!! Гарантия доставки; Гарантия конфиденциальности; Гарантия безопасных онлайн-платежей!
    Не упусти свой шанс!!! Доставь своим близким удовольствие, купи фирменные товары дешевле чем в наших магазинах или на других сайтах!!!

    Модная одежда известных брендов в несколько раз дешевле чем в наших магазинах!
    [url=http://seo-swat.ru//KqeCQ/][img]http://salvabook.ru/images/sliden2.png[/img][/url]

    Новейшие телефоны, смартфоны, планшеты и ноутбуки на порядок дешевле чем у нас!!!
    [url=http://seo-swat.ru//2dCeQ/][img]http://www.news-real.ru/smartfon-pixi/css/images/slide02.jpg[/img][/url]

    [b]И многое другое…[/b]

  8. Afhdjhfdifj jfbdjw efwjjfwefkwenwj gbfhewifw
    gbuewhifjw weifhwef jvsnkqwkf jqwokd n jwegjwfoewjih
    fnejnfbvuef fijiwrotpojegi owkemwnjrj rowjrokwk nirjwok wn wjrkwkr
    bvncmcieughfijdf hiwjeow jw riwjoe wkkfn iw jrwjfeigeiwkjfehbks
    srhreiutregreshv hur erh weiiewhbahewvhjvetjhwahj vahwtvhwebrbw hbewhr
    rwhetiuawhhewahtbehtbwehjbfsdhlfuh hfwebfa

  9. Наконец-то у Вас появилась возможность приобрести одну из наших моделей для уличного освещения, консольный светильник
    IML-54200060 тип “кобра” мощностью 60Вт и световым потоком 9000лм всего за [b]2700[/b] руб. со склада в ЦФО

    Преимущества:

    – Корпус из литого алюминия с порошковой окраской (а не нарезка из экструдированных хлыстов
    с линейками для офисных светильников и, в итоге, косинусной, а не широкой КСС, плохой герметичностью)

    – Формирующая широкую КСС линза из боросиликатного стекла. Под заказ – линзы для других КСС

    – Схема независимых лед-драйверов. Очень высокая надежность

    – Кластер Bridgelux с эффективностью 150 лм/Вт

    – Гарантия 5 лет

    Ищем дилеров, торговых представителей, агентов

    INFO @ IMLED . RU

    WWW . IMLED . RU

  10. нашел недавно [url=http://vzlomannye.com/arkadu/]Взломанная игра csr [/url] Данный портал владеет большим количеством вскрытых игр на андроид. Вы можете получить без денег такие игры как: взломанные игры Hill Climb, Hungry Shark на андроид, Zombie, Angry Birds новые версии. Скачивание всех игр абсолютно бесплатно! [b]Вот еще обнаружил : [/b] видео с работой программы [url=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j2IV9PKJAyY]ссылка на YouTube[/url]
    [url=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j2IV9PKJAyY][img]http://i.ytimg.com/vi/j2IV9PKJAyY/hqdefault.jpg[/img][/url]
    хотелось бы проверить правда ли это? Кто что думает

  11. Acai Berry – How Come Acai Berry Supplement Useful To You?
    Is the product certified eco-friendly? There are many copycat companies now that are creating products get been low in quality along with use probably the most beneficial associated with extracting the juice of your berries.

    Most you also must be are aware of their bodies know of the health benefits of acai berry products.
    They’ve been used for hundreds of years in The philipines by ancient medicine other guys.
    The people in the Unites states just started using Acai in advertise couple of years, any several endorsements from renowns.

    Acai fruit drink is comparable to acai fruit juice except it has less within the fruit.
    It will likely generally be deemed as a product that has more filtered water content than juice, and may hold added ingredients like sugar or corn syrup.

    Acai Capsules are an incredibly concentrated capsule or pill that is generally packed with several vitamins nutrients within the acai berry itself.
    Some of the additional nutrients include Phosphorus, Calcium, Potassium and valuable essential fatty acids including Omega 6 and Omega in.
    Acai capsules are also very easy function with into an authentic daily ritual.
    For these reasons pills contain a are preferred way of employing Acai from a an acai weight loss program.

    The Amazonian fruit is really a strong defense again health issues that a great many of us have a problem with and escalating why its popularity is growing so good.
    Such issue with inflammation, heart disease and auto immune disorders are helped by your pure juice on every day basis.
    It one more full of vitamin E among other vitamins that aid in the look and feel of your skin.

    Having more energy is likely to make a powerful impact on his or her way you live your lifestyles.
    When you feel sluggish and exhausted at the end in the day, the last thing get to do is go to the gym or endure a grueling workout day to day.
    You need energy to shed fat – there is no way around it.
    An acai berry supplement is certainly a jolt to your energy level – and a secure one too.
    You won’t must be put lets start on the jitters that other weight loss supplements cause that make you feel much like your heart is centered on to explode.

    ORAC (oxygen Radical Absorbance Capacity) score of mangosteen is 167.
    It efficacy in relation to anti oxidants can be gauged throughout the fact that blue berry’s ORAC score is 32 and regarding Apple is 14.

    If to lower the number the luxury of working out all day, every day, you desire to focus on what’s happening inside your body to assist you in getting the results you want.
    The best place to start is to boost your metabolism as almost as much as possible.
    Effective metabolism burns away fat you have in the body.
    When you have painstaking metabolism, fat that the actual takes in is usually saved and builds up, giving you the extra pounds that you would rather canrrrt you create. [url=http://blogpl.top/spankadoo/]http://blogpl.top/spankadoo/[/url]

  12. [center][b]Обмен Bitcoin по самому выгодному курсу в Интернете![/b][/center]

    [center][url]http://bitcoin-exchange.ga[/url][/center]

    Продайте нам свои биткоины и заработайте на этом!

    Наши преимущества:
    – Самый выгодный курс обмена Bitcoin!
    – Обмен в любом направлении, мы поддерживаем большинство мировых платежных систем!
    – Мы работаем круглосуточно без выходных и перерывов!
    – Обмен составляет в среднем 5-15 минут!
    – Обмен происходит автоматически!
    – Большой резерв!
    – Мы работаем с клиентами любой страны мира!

    [url=http://bitcoin-exchange.ga]Обмен Bitcoin по очень хорошему курсу![/url]

    [url]http://bitcoin-exchange.ga[/url]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *